Detective tells jury he retrieved metal bar from Tipperary embankment near where Scarlett Faulkner attacked

The late Scarlett Faulknerplaceholder image
The late Scarlett Faulkner

A detective has told a Central Criminal Court jury that he retrieved a metal bar that may have been an agricultural “bale spike” in an embankment in County Tipperary near where 28-year-old Scarlett Faulkner was attacked.

A detective has told a Central Criminal Court jury that he retrieved a metal bar that may have been an agricultural “bale spike” in an embankment in Co Tipperary near where 28-year-old Scarlett Faulkner was attacked.

A 17-year-old girl and a 41-year-old woman are on trial at the Central Criminal Court accused of Ms Faulkner's murder. The 17-year-old accused has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty (GUILTY) to manslaughter. The older accused has also pleaded not guilty to murder.

It is the State's case that the 41-year-old accused is alleged to have been part of a joint enterprise with the teenager to kill or cause serious injury to Ms Faulkner and the older accused's estranged husband.

In his opening speech, Seoirse Ó Dúnlaing SC, prosecuting, told the jury that the motive for the attack was that Ms Faulkner had begun a relationship with the older accused's husband. Mr Ó Dúnlaing said the prosecution would seek to prove that the accused "hunted down" her husband and Ms Faulkner for 24 hours up to about 5.20pm on March 21 last.

The lawyer said the older accused woman "rammed" her husband's van until both vehicles came to a stop near the Birdhill roundabout just off the M7 in Tipperary, between Limerick and Nenagh. The prosecution alleges that the 17-year-old inflicted all the injuries to Ms Faulkner using an iron bar. Scarlett Faulkner died on April 13 last after spending about three weeks in a coma.

In cross-examination, Detective Garda Larry Stapleton agreed with Colman Cody SC, for the teenager, that he retrieved a metal bar from an embankment near the scene of the alleged attack. Asked by Mr Cody if he could give an opinion where the metal bar had originated from his examination of it, the detective said he thought the metal bar was "something used in agriculture, something used for lifting silage bales".

"I call it a bailer spike used in agriculture, that's what it reminded me of," said the detective.

Asked how long it was in that condition, the detective replied: "I'd say years, the thread is worn on it".

The detective was also shown pictures from inside a Volkswagen Touran, which was driven by the older accused woman on March 21 last. The witness was asked to comment on a small tool, which he said looked like a pliers of some sort. Det Gda Stapleton was asked about a Ford Transit van driven by the older accused's husband, which Scarlett Faulkner had been travelling in prior to being killed on March 21 last. Pictures were shown to the jury from inside the van, which showed licence plates, a gun and bolt cutters.

Mr Cody said that when the teenager was being interviewed by gardai she mentioned getting the metal pole from the back of the Touran and that she had used it to hit Ms Faulkner. The lawyer said his client thought it belonged to the older accused's husband as he kept a lot of tools in the vehicles.

The witness agreed that pliers and bolt cutters are the kind of tools that can have many uses and can be used to break into houses and commit thefts. Mr Cody told the witness that the jury would hear about the older accused's husband's previous convictions, some of which he said were for burglary and theft.

Sergeant David Harney, who is the last witness for the prosecution, took the jury through a Powerpoint presentation which put a lot of what the jurors had already viewed - phone activity, messages, maps, CCTV and video footage - into chronological form leading up to the attack at Birdhill. The jurors were also shown a compilation of movements of persons of interest in the investigation.

The sergeant agreed that one of the zoomed-in dash cam footage had captured the fatal assault on Ms Faulkner at 5.20pm on March 21 and the teenager inflicting 11 blows with the weapon. Another clip showed the teenager going into a Chinese takeaway at 8.53pm that night and returning to pick up her order at 9.17pm.

In cross-examination by Marc Thompson SC, for the older accused woman, Sgt Harney agreed that the older accused woman's husband would not be giving evidence in the trial.

"He is not a person who is entirely respectful of the criminal justice system," said Mr Thompson. "That's a polite way of putting it," replied the witness.

The jurors heard that the older accused woman's husband has previous convictions for domestic, commercial and agricultural type burglaries. The witness agreed with Mr Thompson that his client has previous convictions for road traffic offences and theft but none for violence.

In cross-examination, Sgt Harney agreed with Mr Cody, for the teenager, that the older accused's husband has 71 previous convictions, which include criminal damage, burglary, theft, handling stolen property and obstructions of a peace officer. The witness further agreed that the older accused woman had previously secured a safety order and a barring order against her husband.

The older accused woman has also pleaded not guilty to burglary, entering a building as a trespasser and causing criminal damage at an address in Co Tipperary, on March 20.

She has further pleaded not guilty to a further charge of burglary and committing assault causing harm, at an address in Limerick on March 21.

The trial continues on Tuesday next before Mr Justice Kerida Naidoo and a jury of eight men and four women.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice