Tipperary councillor slams Taoiseach’s ‘ignorance’ around water supply project

placeholder image
Nenagh civic offices

‘Who’s going to stop this runaway train’ said Cllr Morris at the recent Nenagh MD meeting

Nenagh councillor Seamie Morris has hit out at Taoiseach Micheál Martin over comments he made during his recent visit to north Tipperary, describing the remarks as “the height of ignorance” and questioning how the Taoiseach could be so misinformed about the proposed Eastern and Midlands Water Supply Project.

Speaking at the November Nenagh Municipal District meeting, Cllr Morris referred to remarks made by the Taoiseach during his visit to Dromineer for the official opening of the new water sports facilities, where the Taoiseach defended the proposed pipeline from the River Shannon to Dublin, describing it as “absolutely necessary” while claiming its impact on the Shannon and surrounding areas would be negligible.

“How can a Taoiseach be so misinformed,” Cllr Morris asked, as he outlined concerns about the advice being provided to Government on major infrastructure projects.

Cllr Morris said he had researched the Major Projects Advisory Group (MPAG), which advises Government on projects costing in excess of €100 million, and questioned the group's assessment of the proposed Eastern and Midlands Water Supply Project.

He told the meeting that two members of the advisory group had links to Uisce Éireann, adding that, as he understood it, they had excused themselves from meetings relating to the water supply project.

Cllr Morris also highlighted the payments made to members of the group, claiming members receive €1,200 for each meeting attended, with the chairperson receiving €1,500.

He questioned the advice provided by the group on the proposed water project, saying it had recommended that the project proceed despite, in its own assessment, abstraction limits being unknown, planning and environmental issues remaining unresolved and affordability not having been demonstrated.

“It's no wonder the Taoiseach and all the people around him are so misinformed,” he said.

Cllr Morris said he remained deeply concerned about the potential environmental consequences of taking water from the Parteen Basin on the River Shannon, arguing that the project could have serious implications for the region.

“You're probably sick of me talking about this, but it will do serious damage,” he told the meeting.

Cllr Morris also raised concerns about river water quality, pointing to the potential for Ireland to face European penalties over water quality failures, while questioning the progress of the proposed pipeline.

“There is no planning permission, no abstraction licence and no funding for this project,” he said.

He claimed that an application for an abstraction licence, which he said was expected in 2024, had yet to be submitted and questioned how substantial expenditure on the project had already taken place in the absence of what he described as secured funding.

He proposed that an invitation be issued to the Taoiseach and senior Government ministers to meet with representatives of the River Shannon Environmental Protection Alliance to hear their concerns and discuss the project.

“Who’s going to stop this runaway train?” he asked.

Cllr Phyll Bugler also expressed support for the concerns raised, highlighting the environmental implications of reduced water volumes in the Shannon and referring to recent periods of hosepipe restrictions during the summer months.

She said the region needed to protect its existing water resources, arguing that reduced river volumes could have implications for water quality and the wider environment.

Cllr Bugler also questioned the role of the Major Projects Advisory Group, saying it was disappointing that environmental concerns raised by groups such as the River Shannon Environmental Protection Alliance did not appear to have received greater attention.

Cllr John Carroll, meanwhile, said the Taoiseach should have engaged more fully with the relevant minister before making his comments during the Tipperary visit.

He said the remarks were premature given the complexity of the project and the issues surrounding it and argued that greater engagement and a clearer understanding of the current position would have been warranted.

The Taoiseach's comments in Dromineer came as the proposed Water Supply Project: Eastern and Midlands Region continues through the planning process. The project, proposed by Uisce Éireann, would involve a 172-kilometre pipeline bringing water from the Parteen Basin on the Lower River Shannon to the Greater Dublin Area.

The project is intended to provide a long-term water supply for the Greater Dublin Area, where approximately 1.7 million people rely heavily on the River Liffey. The proposed pipeline would pass through parts of North Tipperary, including areas near Birdhill, Silvermines, Ballycommon, Portroe and Cloughjordan, before continuing eastwards.

The project has attracted sustained opposition from local campaigners and landowners, with concerns raised about environmental impacts, abstraction levels, water quality and the long-term implications for communities along the Shannon and the proposed pipeline route.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice