Scarlett Faulkner accused denies that threats were anything more than ‘ranting’

The late Scarlett Faulknerplaceholder image
The late Scarlett Faulkner | File

The older of the two accused has denied that messages sent to Scarlett Faulkner's sister, threatening to harm Scarlett, were nothing more than "ranting" and said she didn't have "as much as a piece of rope to do any harm".

A woman who is on trial accused of being part of a joint enterprise to murder 28-year-old Scarlett Faulkner denied to gardai that she "drove" her co-accused's anger before the fatal assault, the Central Criminal Court heard today (Tuesday, November 17th).

Gardaí put it to the 41-year-old that she and others, including her 17-year-old co-accused, "planned, organised and participated in" an assault on Ms Faulkner after the deceased began seeing the accused's husband. They said the accused broke into an apartment, assaulted one of the residents and that she and others used intimidation, threats and violence in their efforts to locate her husband and Ms Faulkner.

When asked if she would agree with the garda summary, she replied: "No, I wouldn't. Not a hope." Gardaí further suggested that she actively sought out her husband and Ms Faulkner while armed with weapons, chased him in her car for nine minutes and rammed him to make him stop before her co-accused attacked Ms Faulkner with an iron bar.

The accused responded by asking gardaí who else had weapons at the scene. Gardaí put it to her that they had chased and viciously assaulted Ms Faulkner leaving her with life-threatening injuries and then went home to have a "debrief". She replied: "That might be your take on it."

The accused also denied that she "drove" anger into her co-accused, saying it was her husband who smashed the windows of the car they were travelling in and chased the teenage co-accused with an axe. She said the teenager wouldn't have gotten out of the car had her husband not "drove the windows in on top of them with a hatchet".

The older accused has pleaded not guilty to Ms Faulkner's murder while the teenager has pleaded not guilty to Ms Faulkner's murder, but guilty to manslaughter. In his opening speech earlier this month, Seoirse Ó Dúnlaing SC, prosecuting, told the jury that the motive for the attack was that Ms Faulkner had begun a relationship with the older accused's husband.

Detective Garda Seamus Kelly told Mr Ó Dúnlaing that gardaí arrested the older accused five days after the assault on suspicion of a conspiracy to cause serious harm to Ms Faulkner. At that time, Ms Faulkner was in a coma at Cork University Hospital but would later be pronounced dead on April 13th.

During interviews at Nenagh Garda Station, the accused said she was hurt by her husband's betrayal and can never remarry because to do so would be frowned upon in Traveller culture. Gardaí put it to her that she sent messages to Scarlett Faulkner's sister threatening to harm Scarlett and within 24 hours, Ms Faulkner suffered serious injuries and was fighting for her life in hospital.

The accused described those messages as "ranting" and said she didn't have "as much as a piece of rope to do any harm". She asked gardaí why, if she was out to harm Ms Faulkner, she "didn't go down near her when she was on the road".

She said she was only interested in getting keys to a van which her husband was driving but which belonged to her. She said footage on social media would confirm that she didn't go near Ms Faulkner. The trial continues before Mr Justice Kerida Naidoo and a jury of eight men and four women.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice